The mother-daughter book club is back!
This year the mothers have a big surprise in store for Emma, Jess, Cassidy, and Megan: They've invited snooty Becca Chadwick and her mother to join the book club!
But there are bigger problems when Jess finds out that her family may have to give up Half Moon Farm. In a year filled with skating parties, a disastrous mother-daughter camping trip, and a high-stakes fashion show, the girls realize that it's only through working together Becca included that they can save Half Moon Farm.
Acclaimed author Heather Vogel Frederick captures the magic of friendship and the scrapes along the way in this sequel to The Mother-Daughter Book Club, which will enchant daughters and mothers alike.
Publishers Weekly
Allusions to Little Women, sprinkled throughout this contemporary novel, may well pique the interest of Louisa May Alcott buffs. Frederick (the Patience Goodspeed books; the Spy Mice series) alternates the perspectives of Emma, Megan, Cassidy and Jess, members of a mother-daughter book club who are reading Little Womenwhile adjusting to their first year of middle school. Emma, an aspiring writer, has grown apart from her former best friend, Megan, who gained entry into the popular crowd after her father's invention made the family rich. Despite her heightened status, Megan isn't altogether happy, since her mother scorns her dream of becoming a fashion designer. Meanwhile, tomboy Cassidy mourns the loss of her father, who was killed in an accident, and Jess misses her mother, who has gone to New York to pursue an acting career. All of the girls are less enthusiastic about the book club than their parents are, but as might be expected, their attitudes change as they become absorbed in Little Womenand its author, who grew up in their hometown of Concord, Mass. The girls' increasing sensitivity to each other's problems is convincing, but the way in which each character finds happiness (during a whirlwind trip to New York City) is more dependent on lucky circumstance than personal achievement. Still, this club's success in uniting a group of disparate sixth-graders may well inspire readers to start one of their own. Ages 9-12. (Apr.)Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information
Children's Literature - Jennifer Mitchell
In this enchanting book, four girls find themselves forced to attend a Mother-Daughter Book Club. Emma, Jess, Cassidy, and Megan are all as different as the women in Louisa May Alcott's Little Women. Megan's father has propelled her family into a new socio-economic bracket that has made her leave her old "book club" friends behind her, and her mother's non-conformist plans are complicating Megan's life. Cassidy and her family must struggle to overcome an unexpected death. Her supermodel mother is fearful of letting "tomboy" Cassidy do anything risky. Hopefully, her new friends will help her become more ladylike. Two problems are plaguing Cassidy: she just found out about an ice hockey team that is having tryouts, and Cassidy's mother is talking across the Internet to a mysterious man. Jess and Emma have been best friends their entire lives, but when Emma puts Jess in a tough situation, will Jess's mom be there to help? Emma is a talented cook and writer, but she also has some seemingly "unconquerable" problems that she must face up to. This book is a wonderful insight into the world of teenage girl interactions. It is good for learning about female bullying, character change, setting, and point of view and would partner well with Emma-Jean Lazarus Fell Out of a Tree.
Children's Literature - Claudia Mills
The Anne of the title is Anne of Green Gables, and in this sequel to The Mother-Daughter Book Club, the girls and their mothers use Anne Shirley's trials and tribulations as a reference point for their own year of challenges and growth. Megan must wrestle with conflicting loyalties when her former friend, popular "queen bee" Becca, is invited to join the group. Cassidy is determined not to like her widowed mother's first-ever boyfriend, distinctly unexciting accountant Stanley Kinkaid. Emma is the victim of Becca's scheming when they are forced to work together on the school newspaper. And Jess and her family, staggering under an unexpected, crippling tax burden, face the loss of their beloved Half-Moon Farmunless the Mother-Daughter Book Club can work together to save it, of course. The alternating chapters, each told from a different girl's point of view, make for some initial confusion, as the reader needs to sort out not only the four mother-daughter pairs, but the attendant siblings (especially attractive older brothers), fathers, and pets, as well as another whole cast of characters from school: Becca's Fab Three trio, teachers, and the requisite boys. The generic voice of each girl's first person narration gives no way of telling the girls apart. But as the year goes on, the various story lines become easier to follow, and despite some over-the-top slapstick scenes, they all build to a satisfying, Anne-worthy conclusion. Reviewer: Claudia Mills, Ph.D.
School Library Journal
Gr 5-8 The cast of The Mother-Daughter Book Club (S & S, 2007) is back. Now the girls are in seventh grade, each responding to the social and academic challenges of middle school and impending teen years. This year, the club is reading books by Lucy Montgomery, starting with Anne of Green Gables . Each member and her mother find something to relate to in the books, even the snarky Becca Chadwick who, with her dictatorial parent, joins the club. Different perspectives are provided as each chapter is told in the alternating voices of Emma (writer), Jess (farm girl), Cassidy (athletic tomboy), and Megan (fashion diva). The pace is fast, the concerns and emotions real. The girls are gutsy problem-solvers, with plausibly presented emotions. Adult characterizations, however, are almost clichéd (Emma's mother, for example, is especially bright as she's a librarian, and the patience of Cassidy's mom's love interest doesn't falter until the final pages). The resolution is a bit romanticized but satisfying. As in the first book, Frederick connects a classic title to contemporary problems.-Maria B. Salvadore, formerly at Washington DC Public Library
Kirkus Reviews
The eclectic group returns for a year of discussion centered on Lucy Maud Montgomery's Anne of Green Gables series. In a structure similar to Karen Joy Fowler's The Jane Austen Book Club, seventh-graders Cassidy, Megan, Jess and Emma's life circumstances run parallel to characters and scenes in the books they are reading. Megan's former "Fab Four" girlfriend, Becca, and her mom join the book group, which adds a bit of spicy acrimony. Megan, caught between her book-club crowd and the snooty "Fab Three," manages to bring the two together in a large-scale fundraising effort to help Jess's family save their historic small farm. Frederick hones her writing for this outing, with chapters in the girls' alternating voices supplying humorous disasters, suspense and excitement as she suggests the virtues of ethical behavior while remaining cognizant of typical tween "queen bee" attitudes. References to key Montgomery quotes in chapter headings and dialogue with lists of "Fun Facts About Maud" create a nice blend of modern and classic themes to stimulate discussion. (Fiction. 10-13)
Read More