Courting Failure: How School Finance Lawsuits Exploit Judges' Good Intentions And Harm Our Children (Koret Task Force on K-12 Education)

by Eric A. Hanushek, Williamson M. Evers (Contribution by), Paul Clopton (Contribution by)

Overview

Perhaps the most significant recent change in policy discussions about school finance has been the introduction of the court's making decisions about funding schemes. The focus of the lawsuits has been funding disparities across school districts, which, generally, have led to increased shares of funding. Yet, until recently, virtually no subsequent analysis has investigated whether student outcomes tended to be more equal after spending was equalized.

Courting Failure examines the issues involved in school funding adequacy in light of recent court cases and shows that judicial actions regarding school finance-related to either equity or adequacy-have not had a beneficial effect on student performance. The expert contributors explain why low achievement is not inevitable for disadvantaged students and why school resources are not the dominant factor in whether students "beat the odds." They show that cost studies on the price of an adequate education turn out to be more politics than science. And they tell how many districts often do not spend the funds they have in the manner needed.

These well-researched essays reveal that simply throwing more resources at the problem has not brought about a solution-because measures of school resources do not provide guidance about either the current quality of schools or the potential for improving them. The expert contributors call for more realistic changes centered around accountability, incentives, and more-informed parents and policymakers.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780817947828
Publisher:	Hoover Institution Press
Publication date:	11/28/2006

About the Author

Eric A. Hanushek is the Paul and Jean Hanna Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution. He serves as a member of the Board of Directors of the National Board for Education Sciences.

Table of Contents

Introduction   Eric A. Hanushek     xiii
Campaign for Fiscal Equity v. New York: The March of Folly   Sol Stern     1
TheLegal Backdrop to Adequacy   Alfred A. Lindseth     33
High-Poverty, High-Performance Schools, Districts, and States   Herbert J. Walberg     79
High-Spending, Low-Performing School Districts   Williamson M. Evers   Paul Clopton     103
Thorough and Efficient Private and Public Schools   Paul E. Peterson     195
How Can Anyone Say What's Adequate If Nobody Knows How Money Is Spent Now?   Marguerite Roza   Paul T. Hill     235
Science Violated: Spending Projections and the "Costing Out" of an Adequate Education   Eric A. Hanushek     257
Adequacy beyond Dollars: The Productive Use of School Time   E. D. Hirsch Jr.     313
Funding for Performance$dA Policy Statement of the Koret Task Force     329
Index     357