Publishers Weekly
This sequel to Birdsall's National Book Award winner, The Penderwicks, has even more charm than the original. The prologue hits the only maudlin note, flashing back to Mrs. Penderwick on her deathbed as she instructs her husband's sister, Claire, to make sure he finds love again after sufficient mourning. The Penderwick sistersRosalind, Jane, Skye and Battylearn of this valediction four years later when Aunt Claire begins arranging blind dates. An emergency MOPS (Meeting of Penderwick Sisters) hatches the Save Daddy plan, in which the girls orchestrate dates so dreadful their father will see widowed life is best. Neighbors on Gardam Street include football-playing brothers Nick and Tommy (the latter plays Tracy to Rosalind's Hepburn), and two newcomers: a widowed professor and her toddler baby. Middle sisters Jane and Skye, who share a room but nothing else, steal the show by swapping homework assignments with hilariously catastrophic results. It's sheer pleasure to spend time with these exquisitely drawn characters, girls so real that readers will feel the wind through their hair as they power down the soccer field. Ages 812. (Apr.)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Children's Literature - Keri Collins Lewis
School has begun and the Penderwicks' summer adventures at Arundel are dramatic yet full of fond memories. Reliable Rosalind is settling into seventh grade and proudly shoulders a new responsibility: supervising her sisters after school without a babysitter. Life in the house on Gardam Street seems reassuringly routine: Jane writes her Sabrina Starr books, Skye continues to love all things orderly such as math and science, and Hound keeps Batty company on her many exploits. Then Aunt Claire comes to visit, and brings with her a letter written by Mrs. Penderwick before she died of cancer. In it she encourages Mr. Penderwick to find someone new to love so he will not be lonely, and Aunt Claire has already arranged the first blind date. Suddenly, the girls are having a MOPSMeeting of Penderwick Sistersto formulate a plan to save their father from the horrors of dating, and to save themselves from a stepmother. As their well-intentioned strategy becomes more complicated and requires more deception, each of the Penderwick sisters finds herself challenged by personal demons, which provides several engaging sub-plots to the main story. Jane and Skye's homework swap results in triumph and tragedy; Rosalind has mixed emotions about her neighbor Tommy; and Batty becomes friends with Gardam Street's newest residents Iantha, the astrophysicist, and her toddler son Ben. In true Penderwick fashion, one escapade after another finally culminates in happy endings for all. The charming sequel to Jeanne Birdsall's National Book Award-winning novel The Penderwicks, this evenly paced story remains true to the unique characters readers love while bringing each Penderwick new tests andopportunities to grow. While some may find fault with the sweet innocence, predictability, and tidy conclusion of the plot, parents and kids searching for well-written, family-oriented books will be delighted the Penderwicks are back. Reviewer: Keri Collins Lewis
School Library Journal
Gr 4-8- The Penderwick sisters are back. Their Aunt Claire has come for a visit, bringing with her a letter from their late mother that encourages their father to date, and an immediate crisis ensues, as the girls assume that this is the first step on the treacherous road to having a stepmother. After frantic consultation, they implement the "Save Daddy" plan, designed to set him up with perfectly dreadful women so that he will not want to date again. Numerous subplots add to the domestic drama. Skye struggles with her temper on the soccer field. Rosalind and neighbor Tommy experience a frustrated romance. Skye and Jane switch homework assignments, leading to a school performance of Jane's Aztec drama, with everyone thinking that it was penned by Skye. While the solution to the dating dilemma can be seen from the beginning, the sisters are so caught up in their drama that they can't see who's right next door. Laugh-out-loud moments abound and the humor comes naturally from the characters and situations. Especially funny is the scene in which the youngest Penderwick hides in the car hoping to spy on one of her father's dates. Like much of the book itself, this scene resolves itself in a tender moment between father and daughter. This is a book to cherish and to hold close like a warm, cuddly blanket that you draw around yourself to keep out the cold.-Tim Wadham, Maricopa County Library District, Phoenix, AZ
Copyright 2008 Reed Business Information.
Kirkus Reviews
This return to the Cameron, Mass., cul-de-sac home of the Penderwicks-romantic seventh-grader Rosalind, temperamental sixth-grader Skye, dramatic fifth-grader Jane, four-year-old Batty, and their widowed college-professor father, Martin, whom readers met in Birdsall's 2005 National Book Award-winning novel-begins with a visit from his sister, the girls' affable Aunt Claire. She has brought a pale blue envelope entrusted to her by their beloved mother years earlier; it contains a deathbed note in which Elizabeth Penderwick encourages her husband to date again. The girls, horrified, formulate a "Save Daddy Plan," but they are, of course, doomed to failure. While observant readers will deduce the denouement on page 13, Batty makes it perfectly plain a little further along: "I say Daddy should date the [sweet, young, widowed, also-an-academic] lady next door, and then I could play with her baby." Out of the mouths of babes . . . . The rest of the story is a pleasant ramble of a read, replete with well-intentioned scheming, adolescent crushes, horrible homework disasters, soccer, secrets, school dances and lots and lots of literary allusion (and yes, a wedding). (Fiction. 8-12)
From the Publisher
Starred Review, School Library Journal, March 2008:
"This is a book to cherish and to hold close like a warm, cuddly blanket that you draw around yourself to keep out the cold."
Starred Review, Booklist, May 1, 2008:
"Just the sort of cozy fare that's missing in today's mean-girl world."
Starred Review, Publishers Weekly, April 28, 2008:
“It's sheer pleasure to spend time with these exquisitely drawn characters, girls so real that readers will feel the wind through their hair as they power down the soccer field.”
Review, San Francisco Chronicle, April 27, 2008:
"Birdsall writes with amazing grace."
Review, Parade, June 22, 2008:
"[A]n old-fashioned (in a good way) read with well-drawn characters, warmth, and humor."
Review, The New York Times Book Review, July 13, 2008:
"Birdsall's second novel . . . offers comforting comedy."
From the Hardcover edition.