Choice Cuts documents
Widespread Panic's (the last of the old-school
jam bands) tenure with
Capricorn Records, from 1988 when
Space Wrangler was reissued (from its original incarnation on
Landslide) through to 1999's
'Til the Medicine Takes 11 years later. There's a huge problem with compilations like this: first,
WP are better witnessed live than heard in a recording studio. The second is that, with a group like this, band choices are likely to be wildly divergent from the choices of fans. That is certainly the case here.
Space Wrangler is a great case in point: the two cuts chosen from it, a cover of
J.J. Cale's
"Travelin' Light" and the band's own
"Chilly Water," are OK -- the latter more representative than the former. But, that said, what was so revolutionary about
WP on that recording was the CD issue with the bonus jam that combined
Robert Johnson's
"Me and the Devil Blues" and
Talking Heads'
"Heaven." There is still nothing like it out there.
"Travelin' Light" gets to the band's more intense moments, but nothing like the dreamy intensity of that medley. On the second, self-titled album, while
"Love Tractor" was a quirky crowd-pleaser live, its studio version feels stilted, though the consolation prize is the funky, horn-driven
"Weight of the World," with
Wayne Jackson and
Andrew Love of
the Memphis Horns prefiguring
WP's gig with
the Dirty Dozen Brass Band by a decade. The trippy
"Papa's Home" from
Everyday is here, along with a nondescript pair from
Ain't Life Grand (
"Blackout Blues" sounds like it was deeply influenced by
Dickey Betts'
country-ish material) and the slippery
funk of
"Rebirtha," which must have pleased Deadheads since it sounds like lead singer
John Bell on an outtake from
Terrapin Station. There are three cuts from
'Til the Medicine Takes and a pair from the underrated live monster
Light Fuse, Get Away from 1998. These cuts,
"Pickin' Up the Pieces" and
"Pigeons" (particularly the former), are fine examples of the kind of snap, crackle, and spaced-out musicianship that
WP are capable of when they are on. It's true that these are shorter cuts, but the energy is all in there. This is a mixed bag. It's an OK intro for somebody new to
Widespread Panic, but for veterans it's a nonevent. ~ Thom Jurek