Plato Papers: A Novel by Peter Ackroyd | eBook

Richard Dyer

The Plato Papers' is a serious divertissement, a brilliant fabulation that is the product of a playful, engaged, and well-stocked mind.
— Boston Globe

Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly

Is each century doomed to misinterpret previous ones? That's the central question of Ackroyd's new book, more a Swiftian compendium of social folly than a novel, satirizing many of today's intellectual shibboleths. In the year 3700, a public orator named Plato educates the masses about the important texts and beliefs of previous ages. It's an imperfect archeology, though, since destroyed texts and lost information cause him to attribute On the Origin of Species not to Charles Darwin, but to Charles Dickens, placing that volume in Dickens's line of melodramatic or romantic novels. He also puzzles over the computer age, rueing the "despair engendered by the cult of webs and nets which spread among the people" and cites Edgar Allan Poe's Tales and Histories as "the unique record of a lost race." Eventually, Plato begins to suspect that his knowledge about earlier culture is fundamentally incorrect, but as he moves beyond generally accepted assumptions, he runs afoul of those in power. He's placed on trial and is forced to defend himself against accusations of "corrupting the young by spinning lies and fables." Biographer (The Life of Thomas More) and novelist (Chatterton) Ackroyd displays his encyclopedic knowledge of world literature in this philosophical satire, rendering this effort witty and cerebral. The humor is especially sharp in the sections listing common words and phrases from centuries before, and their wildly creative definitions: "pedestrian: one who journeyed on foot; used as a term of abuse, as in `this is a very pedestrian plot.'" Or "yellow fever: the fear of colour." Toward the end of the book, Ackroyd creates a sense of how Plato's search for knowledge affects him as an individual, a welcome development in keeping the plot connected to the experimental narrative. Other elements are by turns highly intellectual, jokey, lofty and fragmented, but Ackroyd delivers a constant stream of surprising linguistic, satiric twists that many armchair cultural theorists will relish. (Jan.) Copyright 1999 Cahners Business Information.

Library Journal

No, not that Plato. This is the 37th-century orator and scholar from London, who regularly regales his audiences with reports from the Age of Mouldwarp (c. 1500-2300); though fervent in his research, Plato makes some incorrect assumptions due to limited historical evidence--e.g., he believes Darwin's The Origin of Species is a comic novel. Plato also defends the city's "guardians" in their views of Mouldwarp as a soulless society with no redeeming value, until he takes a metaphysical journey to that time. There he finds an understanding that unnerves his contemporaries so much that he is charged with spinning lies and banished from the city. The versatile Ackroyd (The Life of Thomas More) has fun particularly deconstructing the 20th century through decidedly different eyes, and the novel can be enjoyed on that somewhat amusing level. The author, however, seems to be reaching for some larger statement (futile searches for "truth," the commonality of man through the ages?) that was lost on this reviewer. A likable enough book, though it will appeal more to the brain than to the heart. For larger collections.--Marc A. Kloszewski, Indiana Free Lib., PA Copyright 2000 Cahners Business Information.

Time Magazine

If watching its hero jump to false conclusions about the past were the entire point of The Plato Papers, the book would amount to an amusing but decidedly donnish diversion. And for many readers, that would be quite good enough. Plato's attempts to redefine old words are instructively wrong-headed ; "rock music: the sound of old stones"; "telepathy; the suffering caused by 'television.'"

But Ackroyd endows Plato with several intriguing complexities, including, literally a Soul with whom he converses. He senses that many of his historical judgements are mistaken and asks his Soul to tell him what it was really like. Soul refuses: "I am not permitted to dwell on such things. You are becoming. I am being. There is a difference."

Plato's lonely quest for the truth involves some tricky time travelling that takes him back to London during the Mouldwarp era. [The present day.] (Those familiar with Plato's Republic will note with interest that the destination of this journey is a vast cave.) The tales Plato tells on his return do not sit well with the governing authorities, and meets a Socratic fate, put on trial for corrupting the young. By this point, Ackroyd's lively tale has shaded into an invigorating meditation on the changelessness, after no matter how many eons, of human nature and uneasiness with the familiar.

Rubin

[An] extraordinary new novel. The Plato Papers is not science fiction. It is not about space travel or advanced technology. Nor is it about biological evolution or strange species encountered on other planets. But, like the best science fiction, it is allegorical, suggestive, and strikingly imaginative.
—The Christian Science Monitor

John Sutherland

...extremely funny...Admirers of Ackroyd will find The Plato Papers richly revealing.
—The New York Times Book Review

From the Publisher

"Richly revealing. . . . Unlike anything else Peter Ackroyd has written. . . . A jeu d'esprit."
—The New York Times Book Review

"A lively tale and an invigorating meditation on the changelessness, after no matter how many eons, of human nature."
—Time

"A serious divertissement, a brilliant fabulation that is the product of a playful, engaged, and well-stocked mind."
—The Boston Globe

"A little book that raises some big questions. . . . You can finish it in a couple of hours. But if you read it carefully, you'll be thinking about it for days."
—Philadelphia Inquirer

"Peter Ackroyd is a visionary, as The Plato Papers makes clear. This is one of the oddest but most important and original novels to appear in many years. This masterpiece of contemporary writing will thrill and entertain readers for years to come, but it will do more than that: it will enlarge their vision, stimulating organs long forgotten and never known."
—Jay Parini, author of The Last Station and Robert Frost: A Life

"What makes The Plato Papers notable is not its fantastic invention but its intelligence...Excellently written...with a truly Socratic curiosity, making The Plato Papers a philosophical good read."
—Malcolm Bradbury, Financial Times

"An invigorating mixture of satire, history, philosophy, morality, and linguistic investigation...it's like T.S. Eliot on speed meets Martian poetry but with better jokes."
—Michele Robert, The Times

"Articulate, comic, wise, delicate, melancholy, exquisite. It simultaneously deconstructs the story of the past and builds its own myth. In short, this is a carefully pulsed breath of a book, with an impact that sneaks into one's dreams."
—John Clute, The Independent

"A fantastic invention—excellently written."—Malcolm Bradbury —>

Plato Papers: A Novel

eBook

Customer Reviews

Read an Excerpt

Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought

Recently Viewed